With interest rates so high and house prices stagnating or even dropping in some areas, is now still a good time to get into buy-to-let, or am I better off just putting my cash into a FTSE global tracker for less hassle?
Quick Answer
Despite high interest rates (4.75% Bank of England base rate) and stagnating house prices, buy-to-let can still be viable for long-term investors focused on capital appreciation and rental income, especially through strategies like BRRR. Diversification or alternative investments like FTSE global trackers offer different risk-reward profiles.
## Why is now still a good time for buy-to-let?
Even with the Bank of England base rate at 4.75% and typical 2-year fixed BTL mortgage rates ranging from 5.0-6.5%, the current market conditions present opportunities for a buy-to-let investor focused on long-term wealth building, particularly if seeking capital growth and rental yield. While house prices may be stagnant or slightly dropping in some areas, this can actually create buying opportunities, allowing investors to acquire properties at more favourable prices than during boom periods. The UK housing market has historically shown resilience and long-term capital appreciation, making dips potential entry points. Furthermore, persistent demand for rental properties, especially in urban centres, tends to support rental price growth, which can offset higher financing costs. For instance, a property acquired for £200,000 at a 5% discount during a market dip, generating £1,000 per month in rent, can still provide a solid yield even with higher mortgage payments than a property bought at peak prices. The key is strategic, long-term thinking rather than short-term gains, especially when considering the potential for capital gains tax at 18% for basic rate taxpayers and 24% for higher rate taxpayers on residential property profits, after the annual exempt amount of £3,000.
## What are the financial considerations for landlords right now?
High interest rates directly affect a landlord's profitability, as mortgage interest is no longer deductible for individual landlords due to Section 24 since April 2020. This means investors using personal names pay income tax on their gross rental income, then receive a 20% tax credit for mortgage interest. For example, a higher-rate taxpayer receiving £1,000 in monthly rent with £500 in mortgage interest might still see a significant portion of their profit eroded by income tax. This often makes investing through a limited company a more tax-efficient option. A limited company pays Corporation Tax at 19% on profits under £50,000 and 25% on profits over £250,000, allowing full mortgage interest deduction before calculating taxable profit. For a property generating £1,200 profit before mortgage interest, a limited company structure could potentially retain more of those profits compared to an individual landlord, depending on their income tax bracket. The standard BTL stress test of 125% rental coverage at a 5.5% notional rate also means lenders are scrutinising affordability more rigorously, requiring higher rental yields to qualify for mortgages. Thus, understanding current lending criteria and tax implications is paramount for any new investment.
## Does stamp duty land tax affect new investments?
Yes, Stamp Duty Land Tax (SDLT) continues to be a significant upfront cost for new investments. From April 2025, the additional dwelling surcharge increased to 5%, meaning most buy-to-let purchases incur this extra levy on top of standard residential thresholds. For example, a second property purchased for £280,000 would incur SDLT at 0% on the first £125,000, 2% on £125,000-£250,000, and 5% on £250,000-£280,000, plus the 5% additional dwelling surcharge across the entire purchase price. This can result in a substantial upfront cost. For a £280,000 buy-to-let property, the SDLT liability would be £2,500 (standard rate) plus £14,000 (additional 5%), totalling £16,500. This is a non-recoverable cost that must be factored into the investment's viability. First-time buyer relief, which offers £0 SDLT on the first £300,000 of a property up to £500,000, is not applicable to buy-to-let purchases, reinforcing the higher entry cost for investment properties. Therefore, investors must financially plan for this substantial initial outlay.
## What about other emerging costs and regulations?
Local councils now have greater powers regarding Council Tax. From April 2025, councils can charge up to a 100% premium on furnished second homes. While BTL properties let on Assured Shorthold Tenancies (ASTs) are usually exempt from this premium (as the tenant pays as the main resident), investors contemplating holiday lets or properties left vacant between tenancies need to be aware. A holiday let, for instance, might qualify for business rates if available 140+ days/year and let for 70+ days, but this is council discretionary. An empty buy-to-let property could face up to a 100% premium after one year and 300% after two years, significantly increasing holding costs. For example, a property with a £1,800 Council Tax bill could face an additional £1,800 if left empty for over a year. Upcoming legislation like the Renters' Rights Bill, expected in 2025 to abolish Section 21 evictions, and Awaab's Law, extending damp/mould requirements to the private sector, also introduce new operational considerations and potential costs, requiring landlords to be proactive in property management and tenant relations.
## Is buy-to-let more hassle than a global tracker fund?
From a purely passive income perspective, a FTSE global tracker fund generally involves less direct 'hassle' once purchased, offering diversification and often lower management fees than property. However, property investment provides tangible assets, potential for leverage, and greater control over returns through renovation and active management. For instance, investing £20,000 into a tracker fund generates returns based purely on market performance, whereas that same £20,000, leveraged with a BTL mortgage, could control a £100,000-£200,000 asset. This leverage amplifies both potential gains and risks. While a tracker requires minimal ongoing input, buy-to-let demands landlord responsibilities, including maintenance, tenant management, and staying compliant with regulations like HMO licensing (mandatory for 5+ occupants in 2+ households) and EPCs (current minimum E, proposed C by 2030). The 'hassle' of buy-to-let is essentially the work involved in actively managing an asset to generate both income and capital growth, which can be significant, but also offers different returns and wealth-building opportunities not available through passive financial instruments. The choice depends on an investor's appetite for active management, risk, and long-term financial goals.
Steven's Take
The core question isn’t whether now is a 'good' time for buy-to-let compared to a tracker; it's about understanding your investing goal. A tracker gives you exposure to market growth without effort, but property offers leverage and the opportunity to add value. With the Bank of England base rate at 4.75% and BTL mortgage rates higher, the market is different to five years ago. You need to focus on strong cash flow and capital growth areas, using a limited company to mitigate Section 24, and be diligent about property selection and management. The current market rewards smart, informed investors, not passive ones.
What You Can Do Next
Review your financial position, considering the current Bank of England base rate of 4.75% and BTL mortgage rates typically between 5.0-6.5%, to determine your lending capacity and stress-test affordability. This can be done with a mortgage broker.
Calculate potential SDLT liability for any prospective purchase, factoring in the 5% additional dwelling surcharge for buy-to-let properties, on gov.uk/stamp-duty-land-tax.
Research the specific Council Tax policies for second homes and empty properties in your target investment area on the relevant local council's website, as premiums can be up to 100% for second homes and up to 300% for long-term empty properties.
Investigate the benefits of investing through a limited company to enable full mortgage interest deduction against Corporation Tax (19% for profits under £50k, 25% over £250k), consulting with a property tax accountant.
Deep-dive into local rental demand and yields in your target areas to ensure properties meet the BTL stress test of 125% rental coverage at a 5.5% notional rate and provide robust cash flow. Use property portals and local agent data for this.
Get Expert Coaching
Ready to take action on market analysis? Join Steven Potter's Property Freedom Framework for comprehensive, hands-on property investment coaching.