How do Hanley Economic's new mortgage criteria compare to other UK lenders for investment property financing?
Quick Answer
Hanley Economic's updated criteria, while improving some aspects, generally fall within the standard UK buy-to-let lending landscape for investment property financing compared to major lenders.
## Understanding Hanley Economic's Niche in Investment Property Finance
Navigating the UK buy-to-let mortgage market requires a sharp eye, especially with current interest rates and regulatory frameworks. Hanley Economic, like many building societies, often carves out a specific niche, offering competitive criteria that can differ from high-street banks. Understanding their position relative to other lenders is crucial for property investors.
### Key Lenders and Their Offerings
* **High Street Banks (e.g., NatWest, HSBC):** Often offer competitive headline rates for standard, straightforward buy-to-let properties with experienced landlords. They typically require a clean credit history and may have stricter criteria for portfolio landlords or complex property types like HMOs. Their standard BTL stress test is usually around 125% rental coverage at a 5.5% notional rate, though some might use higher notional rates or 145% coverage for higher-rate taxpayers.
* **Specialist Lenders (e.g., Paragon, Foundation Home Loans):** These lenders often excel in more complex scenarios, such as HMOs, multi-unit freeholds, or applicants with adverse credit. While their rates might be slightly higher, they offer flexibility and expertise for deals that mainstream lenders might decline. They are generally adept at handling section 24 considerations and corporation tax implications for limited company buy-to-lets, which is crucial given that individual landlords cannot deduct mortgage interest since April 2020.
* **Building Societies (e.g., Hanley Economic, Coventry Building Society):** These often bridge the gap, providing a more personalised approach than high street banks but with generally more transparent pricing than some specialist lenders. They can be more flexible on certain criteria, such as accepted property types or landlord experience, and might be more amenable to specific local market conditions.
### Hanley Economic's Offering in Context
Hanley Economic’s criteria generally align with the prevailing market standard for rental coverage, typically requiring **125% rental coverage at a 5.5% notional rate** for their standard buy-to-let products. This is in line with the current Bank of England base rate of 4.75%, with lenders often adding a buffer to account for potential rate increases. For example, if a property generates £1,000 in monthly rent, the mortgage payment would need to be no more than £800 (£1,000 / 1.25).
Where Hanley Economic might distinguish itself is in specific areas like acceptable property types, maximum portfolio size, or their approach to calculating affordability for landlords using a limited company. They often have competitive rates for standard 2-year fixed mortgages, which currently sit between 5.0-6.5% across the market, or 5-year fixed products, which are typically 5.5-6.0%. For portfolio landlords, a common offering from Hanley Economic might be a specific product for those with fewer than 10 properties, whereas some high-street banks might cap it at four or five.
An example of where Hanley Economic might stand out could be their approach to properties requiring minor refurbishment. While many lenders require properties to be immediately lettable, Hanley Economic might offer a more understanding stance, allowing for certain minor works post-completion, which could save an investor time and bridging finance costs. For instance, a property needing £5,000 worth of cosmetic upgrades to achieve a 'C' EPC rating could be financed, whereas another lender might not consider it unless the work is complete.
## Potential Pitfalls to Consider
While Hanley Economic offers competitive options, it's vital to be aware of potential limitations or areas where other lenders might be a better fit:
* **Niche Product Constraints:** Like many building societies, their product range for highly specialised property types, such as large HMOs (particularly those requiring mandatory licensing for 5+ occupants), may be less extensive than dedicated specialist lenders. Their maximum loan-to-value (LTV) might also be slightly lower for certain complex deals.
* **Portfolio Underwriting:** For landlords with very large portfolios (e.g., 15+ properties), large banks and specialist lenders often have dedicated underwriting teams that might be more efficient at assessing complex finances and aggregated risk. Hanley Economic might require more granular detail on each property, which can extend the application process.
* **Criteria for Limited Companies:** While many lenders offer limited company buy-to-let products, the specific criteria for retained profits, director remuneration, and personal guarantees can vary. It’s crucial to compare how Hanley Economic assesses these factors against HMRC's 25% corporation tax rate for profits over £250k (or 19% for profits under £50k).
## Investor Rule of Thumb
Always compare the total cost of a mortgage, including fees and interest over the initial term, rather than just the headline rate, especially when considering the impact of a 5.5% notional stress test on affordability.
## What This Means For You
Choosing the right lender is about more than just the interest rate, it's about finding a partner that understands your investment strategy and property type. Most landlords don't lose money because they choose the wrong lender, they lose money because they don't understand the lender's criteria for their specific deal. If you want to know which lender is suitable for your investment and why, this is exactly what we analyse inside Property Legacy Education.
Steven's Take
Hanley Economic, like many building societies, is a good option for landlords who fit within their clearly defined lending criteria, often those with smaller or medium-sized portfolios and straightforward properties. They tend to offer good service and competitive rates within their niche. However, for a unique or complex deal, such as a large HMO or a property needing significant refurbishment, a specialist lender might be better equipped. Always use a good broker who understands the entire market, not just the mainstream offerings, to ensure you're getting the best fit for your specific investment property needs.
What You Can Do Next
Assess your property strategy: Determine if your investment property (e.g., standard buy-to-let, HMO, multi-unit freehold) aligns with Hanley Economic's typical offerings for property types and loan amounts.
Calculate affordability with current stress tests: Use the standard 125% rental coverage at a 5.5% notional rate to estimate your borrowing capacity with Hanley Economic and compare it to other lenders.
Review limited company criteria: If investing via a limited company for tax efficiency, scrutinise Hanley Economic's criteria for corporate structures versus specialist limited company lenders.
Consult a specialist buy-to-let mortgage broker: Engage a broker who has access to a wide panel of lenders, including building societies and specialist lenders, to find the most suitable and cost-effective financing.
Compare total mortgage costs: Look beyond the headline interest rate and factor in all fees, valuation costs, and early repayment charges to calculate the true cost of the mortgage over the initial fixed term.
Get Expert Coaching
Ready to take action on financing & mortgages? Join Steven Potter's Property Freedom Framework for comprehensive, hands-on property investment coaching.