My referencing agency flagged a tenant's credit score as 'fair' due to a recently settled CCJ. How should I interpret this for a non-guaranteed AST, and what additional checks or conditions (e.g., guarantor, increased deposit) are legally advisable and common practice in this scenario?
Quick Answer
A 'fair' credit score with a settled CCJ means heightened risk; consider a guarantor or upfront rent, but be aware deposit caps limit security options.
## Navigating Tenant Credit Scores: Mitigating Risk with Practical Safeguards
When a referencing agency flags a tenant's credit score as 'fair' due to a recently settled County Court Judgment (CCJ), it certainly warrants a closer look, especially for a non-guaranteed Assured Shorthold Tenancy (AST). A settled CCJ indicates past financial difficulty, but the 'settled' part shows they've addressed it. Your job is to balance the risk with giving someone a fair chance, while protecting your investment.
* **Require a UK-based Guarantor:** This is often the most effective safeguard. A guarantor, typically a family member or close friend, legally commits to covering rent arrears or property damage if the tenant defaults. Ensure the guarantor is thoroughly referenced, proving they have sufficient income and a strong credit history themselves. This drastically reduces your financial exposure.
* **Request Rent in Advance:** Rather than relying solely on a deposit, you could ask the tenant to pay several months' rent upfront. This provides a significant buffer. For instance, asking for six months' rent on a property letting for £800 per month would give you £4,800 immediately, offering substantial security. This should be agreed upon as part of the tenancy agreement.
* **Consider a Higher Rent-to-Income Ratio for Affordability Checks:** While not a direct security measure, if the tenant's income barely covers the rent, even a 'fair' credit score becomes riskier. Aim for a tenant's gross annual income to be at least 2.5 to 3 times the annual rent. If it's borderline, the CCJ flags this as a potential issue.
* **Enhanced Employer and Landlord References:** Go beyond standard checks. Speak directly to the HR department or the tenant's previous managing agent, not just the provided contact. Ask specific questions about reliability, payment history, and tenancy conduct. Sometimes, a detailed conversation can provide critical context that a credit score misses.
## Common Pitfalls and Legal Restrictions to Avoid
While protecting your investment is paramount, there are legal limits and common mistakes that can lead to problems if you're not careful.
* **Excessive Security Deposits:** The Tenant Fees Act 2019 caps security deposits. For properties where the annual rent is less than £50,000, the maximum deposit is five weeks' rent. If the annual rent is £50,000 or more, it's six weeks' rent. Attempting to charge more, even for a tenant with a settled CCJ, is illegal and can result in significant fines and the inability to serve a Section 21 notice.
* **Discrimination:** You cannot unfairly discriminate against a tenant based on protected characteristics like age, race, or disability. While a CCJ is a valid reason to assess risk, ensure your decision-making process is consistent and documented, focusing solely on financial viability and tenancy suitability, not personal biases.
* **Ignoring the 'Settled' Aspect:** A settled CCJ means the debt has been paid. While it indicates past issues, it also shows responsibility. Dismissing a tenant purely on a *settled* CCJ without exploring further might lead you to miss out on an otherwise good tenant who has turned a corner financially. Always seek clarification and context.
* **Relying Solely on Referencing Agencies:** While valuable, referencing agencies provide a snapshot. Your due diligence should extend to speaking to prospective tenants, understanding their situation, and verifying information independently where possible. Remember, in your buy-to-let business, you are the ultimate decision-maker.
* **Poorly Worded Tenancy Agreements:** Ensure any additional conditions, like requiring upfront rent or a guarantor, are clearly and legally documented in your AST. Vagueness can lead to disputes and legal challenges down the line. A strong, legally compliant agreement is your first line of defence.
## Investor Rule of Thumb
When a tenant's financial history presents a 'fair' risk, your primary goal is to shift that risk, typically onto a solvent guarantor or by securing a substantial amount of rent upfront, without breaching legal deposit caps.
## What This Means For You
Most property investors don't lose money on bad tenants because they skip referencing; they lose money because they don't adequately act on the red flags uncovered during referencing. Understanding how to reinforce a tenancy with additional security allows you to make informed decisions that protect your asset. If you want to know how to interpret complex tenant referencing reports and structure agreements that genuinely protect your portfolio, this is exactly what we analyse inside Property Legacy Education.
Steven's Take
Seeing a 'fair' credit score with a settled CCJ isn't a deal-breaker, but it's a call to action. I look at it as an opportunity to secure the tenancy more robustly. My go-to is always a guarantor, and I'd ensure they pass the same rigorous checks as any tenant. If a guarantor isn't possible, then serious upfront rent, like six months, is the next best thing. You've got to protect yourself, especially with the Bank of England base rate at 4.75% and BTL rates around 5.5-6.5%. Voids and arrears are portfolio killers, so mitigate that risk properly from the start. Don't be too quick to dismiss potential tenants, but don't be a pushover either; find the right balance for your business.
What You Can Do Next
**Thoroughly Vet the Guarantor:** Ensure any proposed guarantor undergoes the same credit and affordability checks as the tenant to confirm their financial stability.
**Consider Rent Upfront:** If no suitable guarantor is available, request several months' rent in advance as a security measure, ensuring it's clearly outlined in the AST.
**Review Affordability Ratio:** Double-check that the tenant's income allows for comfortable rent payments, aiming for a 2.5x to 3x income-to-rent ratio monthly.
**Document All Conditions:** Ensure all agreed-upon conditions, such as guarantor agreements or upfront rent, are formally and legally documented within the tenancy agreement.
**Stay Within Deposit Limits:** Strictly adhere to the Tenant Fees Act 2019 deposit caps (5 or 6 weeks' rent) to avoid legal penalties and ensure compliance.
Get Expert Coaching
Ready to take action on financing & mortgages? Join Steven Potter's Property Freedom Framework for comprehensive, hands-on property investment coaching.