What are the new legal obligations for UK buy-to-let landlords regarding pets under the Renters' Rights Act?
Quick Answer
The Renters' Rights Bill, currently awaiting Royal Assent and expected in 2025, will make it easier for tenants to have pets by requiring landlords to consider all requests reasonably and not unreasonably refuse.
The Renters' Rights Act 2025, which came into effect from 1 May 2026, introduces significant changes to the legal landscape for UK buy-to-let landlords, particularly regarding pets. This legislation aims to provide tenants with more security and rights, including making it easier for them to keep pets in rental properties. For landlords, understanding these new obligations is essential to avoid legal issues and ensure compliance, especially with the abolition of Section 21 no-fault evictions from the same date, meaning retaining good tenants is more crucial than ever.
### What are the New Legal Obligations for Landlords Regarding Pets?
From 1 May 2026, the Renters' Rights Act 2025 significantly alters the ability of landlords to refuse pets in their properties. Landlords can no longer enforce a blanket ban on pets through clauses in tenancy agreements. Instead, tenants have a legal right to request to keep a pet, and landlords must consider this request and cannot unreasonably refuse it. This shift means that the default position is now that pets are permitted unless there is a justifiable reason for refusal, moving away from the previous 'no pets' stance common in many tenancy agreements. The Act specifies that any refusal must be based on reasonable grounds, such as the property being unsuitable (e.g., a very small flat not suitable for a large dog), or if there are specific leasehold covenants preventing pets.
Furthermore, the Act allows landlords to require tenants to hold pet insurance. This is a key provision designed to mitigate risks for landlords. The insurance must cover potential damage to the property caused by the pet. This stipulation helps protect the landlord's asset while enabling tenants to enjoy pet ownership. Landlords cannot charge an additional 'pet deposit' on top of the standard security deposit, as this would contravene the Tenant Fees Act 2019, which limits tenancy deposits to five weeks' rent where annual rent is under £50,000, or six weeks' rent where annual rent is £50,000 or more. The pet insurance requirement is intended to address the financial risk of pet-related damage without increasing upfront costs for tenants.
### Does this Affect All Buy-to-Let Properties?
Yes, these new pet provisions apply to all new and existing Assured Shorthold Tenancies (ASTs) in England. This means that even if a current tenancy agreement includes a 'no pets' clause, a tenant can still request to keep a pet under the new rules. Landlords would then be obliged to consider this request reasonably. This universal application means that all landlords of residential properties let on ASTs need to review their policies and tenancy agreements. It does not, however, apply to properties let on commercial leases or certain exempted tenancies.
For example, if you own a two-bedroom terraced house let on an AST for £1,200 per month, your tenant can now request to keep a cat, and you cannot automatically refuse. You would need a valid reason, such as a local council bylaw prohibiting cats in the area or a head lease restriction. Conversely, if your property is a small studio flat on the 10th floor, you might reasonably refuse a tenant's request to keep a large dog, citing suitability.
### What are 'Reasonable Grounds' for Refusal?
The term 'reasonable grounds' is central to the new pet policy. While not exhaustively defined, it generally refers to legitimate concerns that outweigh the tenant's right to have a pet. Examples of reasonable grounds include, but are not limited to, restrictions within the superior lease of a flat that explicitly prohibit pets, properties that are unsuitable due to their size or layout (e.g., an extremely small apartment for a large animal), or properties where keeping a pet would breach local environmental health regulations or cause a nuisance to neighbours. Landlords must be able to demonstrate objective reasons for refusal, rather than personal preference or general dislike of animals.
For instance, refusing a request for a goldfish would generally be considered unreasonable unless there's a demonstrable risk. Refusing a large, noisy dog in a block of flats with thin walls might be considered reasonable if it demonstrably breaches noise clauses in the head lease or causes undue disturbance to other residents, as evidenced by prior complaints. The onus is on the landlord to justify the refusal, not on the tenant to prove the pet is suitable. Legal advice may be necessary if a landlord is unsure about the reasonableness of a refusal, or if a tenant challenges a decision.
### Practical Implications for Landlords
These changes require landlords to adapt their approach to pet policies proactively. Firstly, review all existing tenancy agreements and update new ones to reflect the new legal position. While 'no pets' clauses are no longer enforceable, a clause requiring a tenant to request permission and detailing the pet insurance requirement is prudent. Secondly, engage in open communication with tenants about their pet requests. Document all communication and decisions, especially any refusals, detailing the 'reasonable grounds' cited. Thirdly, consider pet insurance providers and policies, and be ready to provide tenants with information on suitable options. The cost of pet insurance for damages might be around £15-£30 per month, depending on the pet type and level of cover.
For example, if a tenant requests to keep a pet, you should respond within 28 days, either granting permission or providing specific, justified reasons for refusal. If you grant permission, ensure the tenancy agreement addendum outlines the tenant's responsibility for the pet, including damage and nuisance, and the requirement for pet insurance. Failure to respond or provide reasonable grounds could lead to a challenge by the tenant and potential legal costs. Given Section 21 has been abolished, maintaining positive tenant relationships and clear, documented processes is more vital than ever for efficient property management.
Steven's Take
The Renters' Rights Act represents a significant shift, removing the blanket 'no pets' rule that many landlords relied on. For us as investors, this means we must adapt our property management strategies. The ability to request pet insurance is a crucial safeguard, but landlords need to be proactive in understanding what constitutes 'reasonable grounds' for refusal. This is not about letting every tenant have every pet; it's about making informed decisions and documenting them thoroughly. Ignoring these changes is not an option, as they are now law and impact tenant retention, which is key to consistent rental income.
What You Can Do Next
Review your existing tenancy agreements: Check for 'no pets' clauses and understand they are no longer automatically enforceable under the Renters' Rights Act 2025. This allows you to prepare for potential tenant requests.
Update new tenancy agreements: Ensure any new ASTs include clauses that allow for pet requests, outline the process for approval, and specify the requirement for pet insurance covering property damage. Consult a legal professional or reputable landlord association for updated templates.
Familiarise yourself with 'reasonable grounds' for refusal: Understand what constitutes a legitimate reason to refuse a pet request (e.g., leasehold restrictions, property unsuitability). The government guidance on the Renters' Rights Act provides further details.
Research pet insurance options: Investigate different pet insurance providers and their offerings that specifically cover property damage. Be prepared to advise tenants on what coverage you expect, which helps mitigate financial risk from potential pet damage.
Get Expert Coaching
Ready to take action on tax & accounting? Join Steven Potter's Property Freedom Framework for comprehensive, hands-on property investment coaching.