My letting agent is charging me a renewal fee every year for my existing tenants – isn't this illegal now after the Tenant Fees Act 2019, or does that only apply to new tenants?
Quick Answer
Charging landlords tenancy renewal fees is now illegal under the Tenant Fees Act 2019, applying to all tenancies from June 1, 2019, and after for renewal.
## Understanding the Legality of Tenancy Renewal Fees for Landlords
The Tenant Fees Act 2019 made it illegal for letting agents to charge landlords fees for tenancy renewals, regardless of when the initial tenancy agreement began. This legislation aimed to reduce costs for both tenants and landlords by prohibiting various fees. Specifically, the Act bans fees related to creating, renewing, or continuing a tenancy agreement for landlords, even if the original agreement predated June 1, 2019. This means any charges for re-signing contracts with existing tenants are not permissible.
### Does the Tenant Fees Act 2019 apply to existing tenancies?
Yes, the Tenant Fees Act 2019 applies to existing tenancies, meaning your letting agent cannot charge you renewal fees for existing tenants. The restrictions on fees came into force on June 1, 2019, and apply to all tenancies entered into on or after that date, and critically, to any tenancy renewed on or after that date, even if the initial tenancy was signed before. This prevents agents from imposing charges for routine administrative tasks associated with extending a tenancy, shifting the cost burden away from landlords. Local councils have the power to enforce this, with fines up to £5,000 for a first offence.
### What specific fees did the Tenant Fees Act 2019 ban for landlords?
The Tenant Fees Act 2019 banned various fees passed from agents to landlords, including those for tenancy renewals, referencing, and inventory checks unless performed uniquely for the landlord's instruction and benefit. For example, charging a landlord £150 for drafting a renewal agreement or £75 for processing tenant references for an existing tenant is illegal. Agents can still charge for services directly agreed with the landlord that sit outside the tenancy agreement process, such as property maintenance arrangement fees, but not for renewal administration. If a BTL property has a rental income of £1,000 per month, an annual £150 renewal fee adds 1.25% to the annual overhead.
### How does this affect landlord profitability and administration costs?
This change protects landlord profitability by removing a common, recurring administrative cost. Before the Act, an annual renewal fee of £150-£250 might reduce a landlord's net rental income by 1-2% each year, impacting overall rental yield calculations, especially on lower-value properties. For a landlord with multiple properties, such as a small portfolio generating £50,000 annual rental income across 5 units, eliminating renewal fees frees up £750-£1,250 annually. This allows landlords to retain more income, improving cash flow and potentially offsetting other rising costs such as increased Council Tax premiums, which can reach 100% for second homes from April 2025, or higher BTL mortgage rates at 5.0-6.5%. It also simplifies **landlord profit margins** by reducing unexpected charges.
### What should landlords do if an agent charges illegal fees?
If your letting agent charges illegal fees, such as a tenancy renewal fee, you should first challenge it in writing, referencing the Tenant Fees Act 2019. Request a refund of any monies paid for prohibited fees. If the agent refuses, you can report them to your local Trading Standards office or the relevant redress scheme they must be a member of (The Property Ombudsman or Property Redress Scheme). Many councils have specific contacts for reporting breaches of landlord-tenant law. It's crucial to understand your rights to maintain **BTL investment returns** and avoid unnecessary expenses. For example, a landlord faced with illegal fees of £200 should immediately contact their local council's private rented sector enforcement team for guidance and potential action. Knowing **which agent fees are illegal** is vital for all landlords.
Steven's Take
The Tenant Fees Act 2019 was a significant piece of legislation, designed to bring more transparency and fairness to the letting process. For landlords, it means your agents cannot charge you for those annual tenancy renewal agreements. This isn't a complex grey area; it's quite black and white. If your agent is charging you a renewal fee, they're operating outside the law. This is money that directly impacts your holding costs and subsequently, your profits. Always be vigilant about what you're being charged, because these seemingly small costs can add up across your portfolio.
What You Can Do Next
Review your existing agency agreement: Check the terms and conditions of your contract with the letting agent for any specified renewal fees by reviewing your signed agreement.
Challenge the fee in writing: Send a formal letter or email to your letting agent, stating that the renewal fee is prohibited under the Tenant Fees Act 2019 (specifically referencing sections concerning landlord fees). Request a full refund of any fees already paid for renewals and provide your bank details for this.
Report to regulatory bodies: If the agent refuses to refund or continues to charge illegal fees, report them to their mandatory redress scheme (The Property Ombudsman at tpos.co.uk or Property Redress Scheme at theprs.co.uk) and your local authority's Trading Standards department (contact details found on your local council's website).
Get Expert Coaching
Ready to take action on tax & accounting? Join Steven Potter's Property Freedom Framework for comprehensive, hands-on property investment coaching.